Friday, January 16, 2009

torture on tv.

i am so, so sick of seeing people tortured on television. I had had it with Jack Bauer a while ago for torturing captives in order to "stop terrorism" (which, by the way, is the OPPOSITE of what torture does).

In cop shows, the torturees are always women. They are almost always sexually abused/raped. They are often partially naked, and they often end up dead (except the one they save at the end).

These shows are lazy. Rather than putting resources into good writing, plots and characters, they throw a naked girl in a dirty room with chains and force the audience to watch as she is tortured, brutalized, or anticipates both while the heroes (strong men and sympathetic, emotionally tortured women) work on finding out where she is.

CSI (all of them), Law & Order (especially SVU), Crimial Minds, Without a Trace; they're all guilty of the worst kind of television - exploitative, sexist, and violent. For no reason.

"The Wire", an extremely violent and brilliant cable show had maybe one scene in all five seasons that matched the above description. They killed loads of characters. But each death had a reason; each instance moved the plot forward or developed the characters. "The Wire"'s writers didn't throw in a torture scene and call it a plot. Once a week. Every week. With new characters who disappear the next week. That's just lazy. And irresponsible.

2 Comments:

Blogger Erin S. said...

totally agree!! I just read a cheesy spy novel on the beach in Honduras and it was ruined by its love of torture and preaching about how it "works." LAME.

Speaking of The Wire (which I still haven't watched), I just read Lush Life by one of the creators of the wire--it's a cop novel based in the Lower East Side and it was written up as one of the best books by the NYT this year...it's fantastic! No torture :)

8:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

TV of the CSI, SVU, and etc variety are called "couch dramas". They are intended to be watched while doing other things and still be understandable plot-wise. I heard an interview once with one of the TV writers (who I believe went on to write for "The Wire"?) and he was telling about his scripts being rejected for having a plot and originality. "People can't follow this while cooking dinner!"
TV is literally the lowest common denominator. A person guessing what briefcase has the million dollars in it is considered a game show. And no one has ever won on "Are you Smarter that a Fifth Grader"! Being smart in America is akin to being Lisa Simpson complaining to Principal Skinner about not being challenged in school "We could make the classes more challenging, but then the dumber students would be in here, furrowing their brows in a vain effort to understand."

1:33 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home